Saturday, 7 July 2012

Save or Splurge on gradual tanning lotions...Garnier V St.Tropez

Hey Girlies!

I do love comparing drugstore and high end products, because I think  it's important to know if splashing the cash is actually worth it or if you're better off saving you're pennies. I've done a couple of these before, but felt like it was time to do a summery themed one which is going to compare the two gradual tanning lotions I've been using. You might know that in about February I became addicted to my St.Moriz tanning mousse and have been applying it religiously every week since (click to watch my St.Moriz tanning routine) However, more recently I've been getting really fed up of putting so much effort into tanning, only to have it go patchy after a few days. Don't get me wrong I still think the St.Moriz mousse is an amazing product for the price, but I wanted something that was less effort and provided me with a constantly nice, even and natural glow. As I'd been saving my Boots points up I thought that I'd see if the St.Tropez Gradual Tanning moisturiser would help me achieve this and now I've been using it for a few weeks I thought I could not only review it, but compare it with the Garnier Summerbody lotion, which I did a full review on last year here-garnier-summerbody


Availability
Both products are available in Boots and Superdrug, although St.Tropez isn't available in smaller stores. 
WINNER- GARNIER
Price
St.Tropez comes in at a very pricey £14.39 for 200ml, whereas Garnier would only set you back a tiny £3.58 per 200ml.
WINNER-GARNIER
Packaging 
I quite enjoy the shape of the Garnier bottle and it does have a nice fresh look about it, however there is no denying that St.Tropez looks a great deal more sleek and classy and is the sort of bottle you want to have out on display.
WINNER- ST.TROPEZ
Application
Application of both is incredibly easy as you apply them like a normal moisturiser and don't have to use a mitt. However the application of St.Tropez seems to leave me with slightly orangey hands if I don't properly scrub them, whereas you can get away with a light rinse or wipe on a towel after applying Garnier and Garnier also seems to glide on better and dry more quickly. 
WINNER- GARNIER
Moisture 
I don't just want the lotions to tan, but also moisturise and Garnier definitely does this better as it feels silky on the skin and blends in beautifully, providing me with the all day moisture it claims to deliver. St.Tropez on the other hand feels thicker and harder to blend in so consequently doesn't feel quite as moisturising.
WINNER- GARNIER
Smell
Both products claim to have got rid of that biscuty fake tan scent and I'm afraid to say both of them lie! St.Tropez smells like they've mixed it with a bottle of perfume and Garnier's 'summer fresh fragrance with extract of Apricot' certainly has digestive undertones. However, they are both much better than Johnson's holiday skin which smells like it was made at Mcvities and I find that if I apply them before bed they get a chance to develop and I can just shower off the smell in the morning.
WINNER- GARNIER (I personally prefer their Apricot cover up to the St.Tropez's perfumey one)  
Colour pay off
I have both the lotions in the darkest versions as I find that you don't really notice much difference at all with lighter ones and I'm really impressed by the colour pay off of both. However, I think the Garnier one takes more applications to achieve a good colour, whereas the St.Tropez one has such an incredible colour pay off that you can notice the difference after just one or two applications and easily build it up to the same colour you'd get with an instant fake tan.  
WINNER- ST.TROPEZ
Shade
It is not only the amount of colour you achieve that's important, but also the actual shade. Both lotions do well in this round as they create very nice natural golden tans with green olive undertones that ensures you avoid the orange TOWIE look or fake look, however St.Tropez wins as the shade is deeper.
WINNER- ST.TROPEZ
Coverage
I imagine that to achieve perfect even coverage from both you should ex foliate before applying them, however I don't want to be constantly ex foliating so it's lucky that the coverage of both is pretty nice and even, although because St.Tropez is darker this makes patchiness on places like the neck and chest and product build up on dry areas more noticeable.
WINNER- GARNIER 
Longevity 
Depending what I'm doing I'd say I apply these on average every other night to every two nights so I haven't really given them chance to properly fade, but as St.Tropez is darker it certainly lasts longer and requires fewer applications.
WINNER- ST.TROPEZ

CONCLUSION-

Splurge with St.Tropez-4 points

Save with Garnier- 6 points

WINNER- Save with Garnier!
So although St.Tropez has incredible colour pay off, Garnier pips it to the post with it's amazing price and great usability. Although I think using a combination of the two is perfect as it still allows you to save money, whilst getting a deeper more instant tan.

Are you a fan of gradual tanners? Have you tried these two or do you have other ones to recommend?

I've just been at work today and now I'm writing this whilst watching the tennis, I can't tell you how excited I was when Murray got through to the final last night, my Mum's already rushed out and bought the strawberries and cream for tomorrow! I was out for a curry with the girls yesterday evening so tonight I'm just going to stay in and watch 'Superstar' as reality tv combined with musical theatre is probably my idea of heaven in a tv show haha

I hope you're all have a great weekend!
Love Meg
x  

12 comments:

  1. Great review! Really enjoyed reading it. I got the St Tropez with Elle magazine but will definitely buy the Garnier when I've finished it. x

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. thank you very much, I'm glad you did! yes I would really recommend it :) xxx

      Delete
  2. I loved Garnier;s but it just took too long to develop. As I'm really pale I had gotten the light version worried the darker would look silly and streaky. I'll definitely be giving it a go now though!

    Laura x
    http://firstclassramblings.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes it does take a while, but much less time if you get the dark version, it's really not that dark so it won't look silly or streaky on you :) xxx

      Delete
  3. I love Garnier!

    thebeautymist.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. Such a great review, I enjoyed reading! :)
    I've not tried the Garnier one before!

    Natasha Carly x
    http://prettylittlelives.blogspot.co.uk

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. oh thank you! I'd really recommend giving it a go :) xxx

      Delete
  5. I love the garnier one, its firmly fixed itself into my beauty regime! Such a bargain and it smells gorgeous too! xxx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ah I'm very glad you agree with my Garnier love hahaa it is such a great product! xxx

      Delete
  6. This is a fantastic review I love how you organized it!!

    Xo

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi what a great review, i love the whole splurg vs save concept. I too love this granier gradual tan. I have just done a review on this product myself; check out the link below if u fancy a read.

    I love the colour pay off and the smell of the garnier tan, it’s definitely one of my top beauty favourites atm. x

    http://thefreckleprincess.blogspot.co.uk/2012/08/gradual-tan-review-garnier-body-summer.html

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for making me a happy bunny!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
 

Blog Design by Bonjour Belle Designs